Sounds like either weak ammo or a grip issue. Call (866) 582-4867, PO Box 1131 13800 Nicollet Blvd Burnsville, MN 55337 2023Guns.com. Including more ambi features and a new and improved grip texture, the Gen 4 delivers an updated take on the classic design. The first difference between Glock 19 Gen 3 and Gen 4 that many sees are the grips. Reply. And you can run the old 90 degree extractor in a newer gun with the right spring loaded bearing. Stay in the know. Besides the swappable backstrap panels, there are few differences between the Gen 3 vs Gen 4 Glock pistols that really add up to much worth talking about. Another curiosity is the Glock 47, which is not offered for sale but is manufactured by Glock for the US Border Patrol. Budget Lever-Action Shotgun: Reviewing GForces LVR410. A B8 at 25 yards is a harsh mistress and has revealed many factory pistols to be lacking for accuracy. The Gen 5 guns also add front cocking serrations (muh press checks) to the slide. It was easily remedied with all updated extractor parts and ejector. This means that a wide variety of parts and accessories can be used to customize a Glock to suit an individuals preferences. Currently, Glock only offers Gen 4 models on select guns to the public such as the large-frame Glocks and the .357 Sig models, but the 9mm and .40 S&W models are LEO only. Please, anyone, an answer would be nice to know. Longslide models of the large-frame Glock pistols, including the 41 in .45 ACP and Glock 40 in 10mm. Its perfectly acceptable; Ive seen results like mine multiple times with Apex extractor, and Im certain thats nothing to be concerned about. When did they stop making gen3. usmc1974 Good points, I really like the 40 to 9 conv so it will mostly be shot this way in 3 gun matches. Glock Factory Trigger Housing w/ Ejector. I've noticed the latter versions have slots to cool down the barrel I assume. Are Gen3 and Gen4 slides compatible with one another? Probably, the biggest issue is the ejector rather than the extractor. For the best experience on our site, be sure to turn on Javascript in your browser. Each Glock comes with its own personality, but all adhere to the companys commitment to reliability. I did as he suggested, but during the process, received my Lone Wolf 9mm extractor. I learned this from troubleshooting a p80 build that took me down a long glock rabbit hole about Gen3s and Gen4 parts. Was it a slip on your part? AW-P320-SS-9-BLK. (Photo: Jacki Billings/Guns.com). I started out with Glocks with an ancient 2nd Gen G21 (serial number AVExxx, so basically right after Glock introduced them). In other words, if you spend an additional $67 on the Apex extractor, youll get $90-100 (rather than $67 alone). Hell, it even ejected to the left and the front of the gun, ejection was so bad. Some guns sent with BTF to Glock return with the 30274 ejector installed. Part number 3 on the Glock Schematic. Gen 3 parts are ridiculously common; Gen 4 and Gen 5 OEM parts are a little less common and a little more expensive. I saw in an email the other day that Lone Wolf now has a stainless extractor available. The Glock 19, for instance, swelled from 1.26 inches at the frame to 1.34 inches, so the guns have gotten a little chunkier. If youre particular about the way your guns look, youll spend quite a bit of time wiping down that Gen 5 slide to get it looking just right. As luck would have it, right after I bought my G19, reports started surfacing about problems with 3rd Gen guns, too, and my G19 exhibited horrific ejection issues. This not only demonstrates the durability of the Gen 3, but it also demonstrates that parts for the Gen 3 can be used with parts for the Gen 5. Some slight filing/polishing could make a difference. You will receive an email every Friday morning featuring the latest chatter from the hottest topics, breaking news surrounding legislation, as well as exclusive deals only available to ARFCOM email subscribers. It should be the same parts that you would use to rebuild a pistol magazine in your early 20s. Many Gen 5 guns can be had with the Glock MOS slide cuts for mounting an optic. Is this gun still being made for "Law Enforcement", and not to forget the "Bad Guys"? Slap in a Gen4 Ejector, or go to the old style extractor. Because it is consistent enough over thousands of rounds (and thus does not require Glock extractors) that Apex is worth $60-70. GLOCK OEM GEN 5 FIXED REAR SIGHT G17/G19 $6.95. The Gen 5s flat grip is a blessing for those of us not partial to the grooves, elevating ergonomics. No markings on extractors. Like the Gen 5 models, the 48 and 43X are both offered in MOS (Modular Optic System) configuration, with a milled slide for mounting an optic. [2022], Sig P320 Vs Glock 19. "-The Last Cowboy. (Photo: Jacki Billings/Guns.com). I specifically bought a 3rd Gen because of the issues with the Gen4 guns at the time (specifically, numerous reports of Brass To Face). The TORO (Taurus Optics Ready Option) is touted as the first-ever optics-ready revolver, and being a sucker for red dots and handguns, I had to try it. The extractor is losing control of the case on the way back to the ejector. Despite the fact that it is a little difficult to shoot, it still shoots extremely well. (Photo: Jacki Billings/Guns.com). Shot the G30sf this morning along side of the G21sf and the G30sf still throws brass onto the bill of my ball cap even with the G21 extractor installed. A possible danger comes in that the 9 ejector's strike point, being closer to the center, is closer to the primer. The Gen 3 was originally modular before modular was even cool, as demonstrated by its versatility. Ask any lefty; there is a HUGE difference between gen 3 and gen 4. The extractor on the 9 sits a few thou deeper in the slide, which makes up for the smaller casehead diameter. Though not all plates are interchangeable, the vast majority of them are, giving you the ability to switch out the slide plate on your Glock for a new look or design. What features are different compared to Glock 22 gen 3? Ejection is perfect except on the last round, then it is weak and erratic. have yet to shoot any of my glocks but still picked up a 47021 for each of them just in case i need them. As indicated in the product descriptions, none of the parts and accessories on this site are official Glock products.Model 17, 19, 26 and 34 with Glock Glock is a federally registered trademark of Glock, Inc. and is one of many trademarks owned by Glock, Inc. or Glock Ges.m.b.H. Glock 17 that I purchased back in 1999-2000 has all the indicators that its a Gen3 but it only has one pin above the trigger. Can I put a Gen4 22 Advantage Arms 22LR conversion upper on my P80 19Glock version? Still had the factory gold grease on the slide. The Gen 5, though, does come with a new DLC coating that looks nice but accumulates finger prints. Excellent post. By continuing to use our site, you accept our use of cookies. The base 48 uses the same frame, but adds a longer (4.2 inches) barrel and slide. The fact that the gun held 17+1 rounds of 9mm is mere happenstance. Gen 3, Gen 5 and so on. The first of them were released in 1998. Apex is an independent manufacturer and seller of aftermarket parts and accessories for Glock pistols, and is not affiliated with or endorsed by Glock, Inc. or Glock Ges.m.b.H. Add to Cart Compare. Power of the ammo didn't seem to matter as to where the case went, only how far it went. The gimmick about the 46 is that it uses a rotating barrel like the Beretta Px4 Storm, a first for Glock. I own two G30sfs and both have a bad BTF habit. $10.99. Note: If extraction problems continue, we recommend replacing the Spring Load Bearing for GlockGlock is a federally registered trademark of Glock, Inc. and is one of many trademarks owned by Glock, Inc. or Glock Ges.m.b.H. MAJ Kelly. Copyright 1996-2023 AR15.COM LLC. It's also the case that some guns - such as the Glock 40 in 10mm or Glock 41 in .45 ACP - are only optic-ready in Gen 4 trim. Glock Extractor Depressor Plunger Spring. Heavier and with a clunkier feel while shooting, the Gen 3 can be a surprise for shooters accustomed to later model Glocks. Swapped out all my gen 3s for that upgrade. So far, they are restricted to 9mm and .40 S&W. The Fora platform includes forum software by XenForo. As a result, Glock owners should keep an eye out for their ejections and replace them if they become too worn down. BrianEnos.com The 40S&W is about .016" deeper than a 9mm. If BTF was the only axle people were talking about, there would be more merit in the discussion. This part of the Apex rifle is worth $60-70 in terms of performance over thousands of rounds due to its constant performance. It wasnt an easy decision to make in the video, and its entirely subjective. My 19x only has 1 pin. [2022], 10mm Vs 45 | 10mm vs 45 acp Side-by-Side Comparison [2022], Double Stack 1911s. Sometimes you can get great deals on plain Gen 3s, and why not take advantage? One large point of contention shooters had with the Glock 19 Generation 3 was the grips being too large for smaller hands. Righties will see it as a nice to have. This peice was putting BTF at least every other shot and many times it was consecutive shots. Had a somewhat older gen3 17 (~2008 mfg) with occasional btf and inconsistent ejection pattern. Which Glock generation is "best" is subjective, although there are a few features and design details that do make some better than others. In addition, the majority of the smaller, internal parts of GLOCK pistols are interchangeable. Must use new style spring loaded bearing with this extractor. I didn't chrono the ammo but it seemed like a few rounds were so weak that the slide didn't want to come back all the way. $19.50. These are the rarest of all Glock pistols and oddly enough command something of a premium on the used market. Appreciate making a different thread. Great information, and a good read. Shameless plug aside, lets continue. Powered by Invision Community. I put in the APEX extractor and bam it's perfect now. Let's review what makes this soft-shooting carry gun so special. The extractors cannot be that different in geometry and still work. By the end of this article, you should have a good idea of what it means when you see "Glock Gen Whatever" and understand what it means, especially if you were thinking of buying a Glock pistolwhich is always a good call. Curious, however, it is; the 46 has a rotating barrel (a la the Beretta Cougar/PX4) and a manual safety as part of the requirements. JavaScript is not enabled on your browser - our site will not work for you as intended. The ejector on the trigger housing pretty much determines which way the empty goes. The only one I have had problems with BTF is the G17 I bought new in 2016. When it comes to taking multiple magazine shots, its critical to choose a extraction angle thats close to your face. It seems as long as there is a round in the magazine, all is well. The Gen 3 continued its upgrades with a universal accessory rail for mounting lights and laser accessories. This time though the cases ejected with authority and all but one case ejected into a nice pile at my 4 o'clock. Which is Better? Curious if everyone running the apex FRE did the fitting checks described here. The Glock 19X has Gen 5 features with a Gen 3 slide and frame. Glock used metal injection molded (MIM) extractors as well as MIM (metal injection molded) extractors at the same time. GLO-3439. . $7.99. 40 ejector. In this article, we'll dive into the differences between the various Glock extractors and explore which one is best for your needs. glock 17 gen 3 (older one with beter materials). This past weekend I put my oem extractor back in my G34.4 but kept the gen 5 ejector in. The Gen 4 brought about a more modern era to the Glock design. The gen 3 ejector #336 doesnt work well with the MIM extractor seen in late gen3s and gen4+. Cured with Apex extractor. I have a 17/5 and 19/5 the new 19 was weak and put empty's here and there, I put the 47021 eject in and its way way better . The issue is generally exacerbated by hotter ammo. Its time to see if the 47021 ejector, which is currently shipping with the G26 gen 5 and G34 gen 5, and the 19X, is as good as the 336, 3027) or 47021 ejectors. All Rights Reserved, Glock Gen 3, 4, or 5: What Generation is Right for Me? Placed in pistols without ejection BTF problems too for the improved ejection pattern. For the record Glock 43s also have the BTF issue as well. Understanding Ammo Choices For The Glock 19: Pros And Cons Of Short Barrel And Regular Ammo, Accuracy And Precision With The Glock New York Trigger, Loading Your Glock 44: A Step-by-Step Guide To Safely And Effectively Load Your Magazine. GLO-3442. It affected Gen 3 and 4 pistols. By the end, you should have a better understanding of which Glock extractor will work best for you. As luck would have it I bought a Gen 3 19 for my wife about a month prior, and it's never had BTF or any erratic ejection. The Gen 3 is a classic, a vintage throwback to the late 1990s. Does the barrel improve performance? The Apex Failure Resistant Extractor for Glock pistols is designed with a more robust extractor claw and utilizes Apex's proprietary geometry. For 9mm 336 is Gen3, 30274 is Gen4/5, the best ejector is the 47201 which comes in the 19x trigger housing part# 47208. More longslide Glocks emerged as part of the Gen 3 models, including the Glock 34 and 17L in 9mm, as well as corresponding models in .40 S&W and other calibers. The extractor, barrel throat, or feed ramp are all possible causes of a Glock failing to extract a spent case. Is there a place to view inter generation changes/upgrades? The 47 is a Glock 17 MOS slide on a Glock 45 frame, so it's not supremely unique by any stretch. It is now possible to change the Standard and Optional language. But if it only happens with certain types of ammo it doesn't sound like a gun problem. Must be one of the 90% (right handed) of people and failed to mention the most significant Glock improvement (on all generations) is the slide release on the right side. Some argue they are the best guns the company has made to date. The Glock Gen 3 series features a single recoil spring, as opposed to the double spring of the Gen 4 and Gen 5 series. Glock pistols have polymer receivers with molded-in steel slide rails. Thanks B, You need to be a member in order to leave a comment. Has anybody ever tried using a non-LCI spring bearing with a LCI extractor? Numerous instances of BTF and horribly erratic ejection to all points of the clock. The 43 is a single stack but the 43x and 48 are different. Not sure which ejector is in it either. The extractor on the 9 sits a few thou deeper in the slide, which makes up for the smaller casehead diameter. The spent case cannot be removed by hand if the extractor hooks are worn down. Must use new style spring loaded bearing with this extractor. Gen 3 improvements included raised texturing, finger grooves (some love 'em, some hate 'em) and the Universal Glock Rail on the frame for mounting a weapon light. Got it, thank you. Numerous different types of ammo were tried, including Speer Gold Dot 124gr +P and Federal HST 124gr +P. The interchangeable parts offer a great way to customize your Glock and keep it running at its best. From hunters and military members, to competition shooters and general firearm enthusiasts, we welcome anyone who values and respects the way of the firearm. His varied interests and hobbies include camping, fishing, hunting, and spending time at the gun range as often as possible. Seems to work ok but out of 200 rounds I had 3 or 4 left standing up it I guess let go of and they did not fully eject. or gen 4? Due to the size of the components, the tolerance stacking issues arose. For those who don't know, the nomenclature for Glock pistols is the patent number. Qty in . You might have heard something about different Glock generations as the company has periodically renewed, updated, and changed their pistols. Anyone have any suggestions of where to look? The 17M has Gen 5 features with a Gen 4 slide, frame and internals, including the omitted finger grooves, a flared magwell and the Glock Marksman Barrel. What is best in life? Designed by Elegant Themes | Powered by WordPress. It is a Gen3 frame with a Gen2 top end on it. Serving up a new grip area, complete with finger grooves, the Gen 3 also brought with it thumb rests on each side of the pistol for a more comfortable and natural grip. Rounding out the Glock 19 generations, the Gen 5 is the newest of the new. The owner might have fired a box of ammo through it, but that's it. The store will not work correctly in the case when cookies are disabled. The grip texture has changed, from three to four, and the grips have been slightly reduced in size. The standard ejector is used in most Glock pistols, while the small and large frame ejectors are used in some of the larger models. document.getElementById("copyright_year").innerHTML = new Date().getFullYear(); Must use new style spring loaded bearing with this Glock LCI Extractor. Many Glock 19 holsters, for instance, will fit all generations; some will only fit up to Gen 3. Components such as the frame, slide, barrel, trigger, and sights can all be changed or adjusted to create a unique firearm. The Gen 4 also delivered more ambi features for left-handed shooters including the addition of an ambidextrous magazine release. Never a problem. People may require this type of answer because of their specific extraction or ejection problems. I replaced the extractor in my gen3 g19 with the Suarez and shot 150 rounds. An example of a reformated spread sheet similar to FRM-72-26, minus any errors or omission, would be valuable. For one, you have parts compatibility. Since its introduction in 1988 as part of the Generation 3 series, the Glock 19 has been a runaway hit. The gun includes the Glock Marksman Barrel and omits finger grooves (Gen 5 features) but otherwise has a Gen 3 slide, frame and small parts, and is wrapped up with an FDE finish. I dont have the P/N details on hand but my observations concerning G19s: My gen 3 G19 went back to Glock twice for brace to face. 30274 made my BTF issue pretty much go away in my Gen 3. I'm happy with it now. Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy. Thanks for doing the testing (and thanks to the guy bumping the thread).
